The points seemingly in defense of the Christian faith adduced by Michael Hoffman, in fact, create the illusion of orthodoxy of Catholic defense against Judaism, but open the way to three things utterly condemned by all Church teaching and tradition for two thousand years.
One) one may allow that the Jews who are simply Jews in name, might not be part of the condemnation the Church has always made of all Jewry by fact of their being part of the mob which called for the death of Christ - by simply confessing to be a Jew.
No so- they are condemned. Only an individual Jew is not condemned unless and only when that individual recants that position of the Jews: their perfidy and condemnation of Christ and their Deicide which they committed against him; which Deicide makes them sons of perdition with Judas Iscariot at all times otherwise. See - The Coming of the Antichrist: The Son of Perdition
Two) proposing that the Freemasonic heretic "bishop" Williamson be considered a proponent of Orthodox Catholic profession of faith simply because he seems willing to argue numbers about the pseudo-holocaust of the Jews. Freemasonry as part of Gnosticism, which it always is part of, with Gnosticism shares completely the utter condemnation of the Church and damnation by God always and completely forever.
Three) trying to call the arch-heretic and apostate - anti-pope and antichrist "Benendict XVI" Josef A. Ratzinger, an actual Bishop and Pope, which he could never be.